Sets Revisited: Analyzing the 2012 Panini Contenders Football Rookie Autograph Checklist

One set that remains near and dear to my heart is the 2012 Panini Contenders Football set. Just a couple months before the set came out, I joined the COMC Team. This particular set has the distinct honor of being one of the first sets that I ripped with my fellow wax busting co-workers.

I’m not a big fan of a large autograph checklist, and the mammoth 145-card base and short print autograph checklist (not including insert autos) for this set was simply unbearable. Even though autographs drop at five per box for Contenders, more often than not your hits would wind up being 4 players who’s names you needed to google and one more desirable auto. We may never know the true print runs of base autos for sets like Panini Contenders, Topps Chrome, etc, but it’s realistic to believe that one would have open four or five cases (12 boxes per case x 5 autos per box = 60 autos per case), to acquire a complete set from a 145-card autograph checklist from this set.

Let’s look at who these 145 names were that made up this enormous set list from 2012 before we deep dive into what cards are worth actually investing in from the 2012 Panini Contenders set. For those who are playing along at home, be sure to tally the number of times you ask yourself, “Who?”:

101. Alfred Morris SP
102. Adrien Robinson
103. Andre Branch SP
104. B.J. Coleman SP
105. B.J. Cunningham
106. Bobby Rainey
107. Bobby Wagner SP
108. Brandon Hardin
109. Brandon Taylor
110. Bruce Irvin
111. Bryce Brown SP
112. Case Keenum
113. Casey Hayward
114. Chandler Harnish
115. Chandler Jones
116. Chris Polk
117. Chris Rainey SP
118. Josh Gordon SP
119. Coty Sensabaugh
120. Courtney Upshaw SP
121. Cyrus Gray
122. Dan Herron
123. Danny Coale
124. David DeCastro SP
125. Nigel Bradham
126. Deangelo Peterson SP
127. Demario Davis
128. Derek Wolfe SP
129. Devon Still SP
130. Devon Wylie
131. Dont’a Hightower SP
132. Dontari Poe SP
133. Dre Kirkpatrick SP
134. Bill Bentley
135. Jeff Demps SP
136. Josh Cooper
137. Fletcher Cox SP
138. George Iloka SP
139. Gerell Robinson
140. Rod Streater
141. Harrison Smith SP
142. Jamell Fleming
143. James Hanna SP
144. Janoris Jenkins SP
145. Jared Crick
146. Jeff Fuller
147. Jerel Worthy SP
148. Jonathan Martin
149. Josh Robinson
150. Juron Criner SP
151. Kellen Moore SP
152. Kendall Reyes
153. Keshawn Martin
154. Kevin Zeitler
155. Kirk Cousins
156. Ladarius Green SP
157. LaVon Brazill SP
158. Lavonte David
159. Luke Kuechly SP
160. Marc Tyler
161. Mark Barron SP
162. Jorvorskie Lane SP
163. Marvin Jones SP
164. Marvin McNutt
165. Matt Kalil
166. Melvin Ingram
167. Michael Brockers SP
168. Michael Smith SP
169. Mike Martin
170. Morris Claiborne SP
171. Mychal Kendricks SP
172. Najee Goode
173. Nick Perry
174. Olivier Vernon
175. Omar Bolden
176. Orson Charles
177. Quinton Coples SP
178. Rhett Ellison
179. Riley Reiff SP
180. Rishard Matthews
181. Ronnell Lewis SP
182. Ryan Lindley
183. Sean Spence
184. Shea McClellin
185. Stephon Gilmore
186. T.Y. Hilton SP
187. Greg Zuerlein SP
188. Tavon Wilson
189. Terrance Ganaway
190. Tim Benford
191. Tommy Streeter SP
192. Travis Benjamin
193. Trumaine Johnson
194. Tyrone Crawford
195. Vontaze Burfict
196. Whitney Mercilus SP
197. Vick Ballard
198. Vinny Curry
199. Zach Brown
200. Brandon Bolden SP
201. Andrew Luck SP
202. Robert Griffin III SP
203. Trent Richardson SP
204. Ryan Tannehill SP
205. Justin Blackmon SP
206. Brandon Weeden SP
207. Brock Osweiler
208. Michael Floyd
209. Kendall Wright
210. A.J. Jenkins
211. Doug Martin SP
212. Lamar Miller
213. Isaiah Pead SP
214. David Wilson
215. Stephen Hill
216. Mohamed Sanu SP
217. Bernard Pierce
218. Nick Foles SP
219. LaMichael James
220. Rueben Randle
221. Coby Fleener
222. Ryan Broyles
223. Dwayne Allen
224. Ronnie Hillman
225. Russell Wilson SP
226. Michael Egnew
227. Chris Givens
228. Joe Adams
229. Robert Turbin
230. Nick Toon
231. T.J. Graham
232. Brian Quick
233. DeVier Posey
234. Jarius Wright
235. Alshon Jeffery
236. Deonte Thompson SP
237. Justin Tucker SP
238. Damaris Johnson
239. Evan Rodriguez SP
240. Kris Adams SP
241. Daryl Richardson SP
242. Lance Dunbar SP
243. Blair Walsh SP
244. Miles Burris
245. Josh Norman SP

 

The Investment Group:

These four superstar quarterbacks need no introductions, as most should be household names at this juncture of their careers. Out of the gate, Andrew Luck was THE rookie autograph in the set that collectors were chasing, with Russell Wilson and Robert Griffin III (more on him later) rounding out the big three autographs to chase from 2012 Panini Contenders.

Injuries in 2015 and 2017 have sidelined Luck’s stellar-up-to-this-point career. That hasn’t deterred his Contenders RC auto from fetching a premium however, as recent completed sales of Luck’s rookie ticket autograph have placed its value in the $550-$625 range.

A Seahawks Super Bowl victory in 2014 and a near repeat in 2015 propelled Russell Wilson to head of the 2012 Panini Contenders class before the ‘Hawks fell back down to earth in recent seasons. Raw copies of his base auto have settled around $225-250 for now, but PSA 10 copies of his white jersey variation autograph have seen sales of more than $600.00

The Kirk Cousins hype train is in full effect as he takes the reigns of the Minnesota Vikings in the upcoming season. RG3 was the Redskins QB to pull when 2012 Contenders was released, but now it’s Cousins that sits firmly as the third best QB in the set. Raw copies of his auto have sat in the $150-175 price range in recent weeks, with a Gem Mint BGS 9.5 hitting an all-time COMC high of $261.99 back in March. These prices should continue to rise, especially if he is able to achieve the same level of success that Case Keenum saw wearing a purple jersey in 2017, but more on him later.

It blows my mind how little love Nick Foles gets in the hobby. To steal a line from a certain NFL commentator, “Now here’s a guy…” who has a career completion percentage of 60.1%, has 61 career touchdowns to 29 interceptions, and oh yeah, a Super Bowl MVP to his name. All of this, and yet his 2012 Contenders auto is hovering at around the $50 range, a far cry from the all-time COMC high of $177.48 that it achieved in June of 2014. At just 29 years old, Foles has a proven track record and this card should be a strong long-term hold.

 The Up in the Air Crowd:

I’ve dubbed these four players the ‘Up in the Air’ crowd because even after nearly six years since product release, the jury is still out on their careers. These are players whose Contenders Rookie Ticket autos still have room to grow, but they will have to ascend upwards as they hit the prime of their careers.

Ryan Tannehill was sidelined by injury last season after leading the Dolphins to a 37-40 career record over his first five seasons. Case Keenum will be under center for the Denver Broncos, reunited with familiar coaches Vance Joseph and Gary Kubiak whom he spent time with in the Houston Texans organization. He led the Minnesota Vikings on a deep playoff run last season.

Alshon Jeffery has always had the talent to be a top-level receiver, but didn’t quite have the production output that the Eagles were looking for in his first year away from the Chicago Bears. With no shortage of talent in Philadelphia, a breakout season from Jeffery could add just another weapon to the team that will already give opposing defenses nightmares. T.Y. Hilton had his best pro season in 2016, but his production was limited in 2017 due to Andrew Luck’s injury. He’ll look to establish himself as a top receiver in the league – and should get plenty of targets to do so.

 The Value Menu:

These next three players have flown under the radar in terms of value in the 2012 Panini Contenders product, but that could all start to change in the upcoming season. Perhaps I’m a little bit partial here, but getting to watch Bobby Wagner play each week here in Seattle has led me to believe he is of the best linebackers in the league. He racked up nearly 100 tackles last season and continues to improve on a yearly basis.

No one has ever questioned Josh Gordon’s on-field abilities, but his actions off the field have led to limited action that saw him missing the 2015 and 2016 seasons completely. With renewed passion, and a seemingly new direction, if he can best his 87 reception, 1647 yard, 9 Touchdown performance in 2013, the Cleveland Browns will certainly be headed in the right direction as well.

Mohamed Sanu has always served his entire career as a very solid wide receiver who has lined up opposite of a superstar. On the Cincinnati Bengals he was overshadowed by A.J. Green, and now for the Atlanta Falcons he lines up opposite of Julio Jones.  He is one breakout season away from establishing himself as a go-to receiver. His Contenders auto can be had for less than $10 at time of writing. Taking a chance on this card could be a high-risk, high-reward venture. 

The Falls from Grace

When this product was released, these two autos were two of the top tier names on the checklist. The hype surrounding their rookie seasons was unreal. Unfortunately, no matter how bullet proof a player might look on draft day, dynamics can change in the blink of an eye.

On the field, Robert Griffin III was electric. By all accounts, his first two seasons showcased that he had all the potential to live up to the hype. However, injuries and concussions have derailed his career to date, and his 2012 Contenders auto has not come close to touching the $350 high watermark sale that it saw back in February of 2014.

Trent Richardson was taken 3rd overall in the 2012 draft by the Cleveland Browns, behind Luck and Griffin III.  A three-year college standout, his first season in Cleveland was not a total bust – as he averaged 3.6 yards per carry over 15 games while tying Jim Brown’s record of 9 rushing TD’s by a rookie running back. He was traded to the Colts the following season and averaged just over three yards a carry splitting time before being waved in early 2015.

 Those Coy Colts:

Thanks for the memories, Chandler Harnish and Coby Fleener! By memories, I’m referring to the number of times that my heart raced every time that I saw a Colts logo on one of autographed cards, only to realize that it was not the much-coveted Andrew Luck short print auto.  Harnish and Fleener were particularly painful to hit because Harnish had a similar pose as Luck, while Fleener’s photo was the same focal length as Luck. Both players were depicted in white jerseys as well. Dwayne Allen and Vick Ballard get a pass here for being depicted in their blue jerseys. 

Most in Stock:

If you read my last installment of Sets Revisited, you’ll know that I don’t like to say anything bad about the ‘hits’ in the product that just didn’t pan out at the professional level. At the time of writing, there were over 20 copies available of the players named above all in the $1 range. Let’s take a look at what these five accomplished in their NFL careers:

Devon Wylie (WR): Devon played six games for the Kansas City Chiefs in 2012 and two for the Tennessee Titans in 2013. Playing in six games in 2012, he caught six passes for 53 yards while primarily serving on kick and punt return special teams.

Bobby Rainey (RB):  Currently a free agent, Rainey suited up for nearly every game from 2013-2016 for three different teams. He’s averaged 4.0 yards per carry over 267 rushes as a commendable back up. Despite only playing 4 games in 2017, he did manage a 96-yard kickoff return for the Baltimore Ravens.

Brandon Hardin (Safety): We may never know what Brandon Hardin could have been in the NFL, as his career was derailed by injuries. In a preseason game in 2012, he was carted off the field with a neck injury and shortly after placed on injured reserve. In the final preseason game of 2013, he broke his scapula, further delaying his first appearance in the regular season. He has yet to make an appearance in a regular season game, but at 28 years old, is still considered as a free agent.

Josh Cooper (WR) – Undrafted out of Oklahoma St, Cooper played in 11 games over 2012 and 2013 for the Cleveland Browns. He caught 17 passes for 166 yards. He had a short stint with the Vikings in 2014 before being released.

Gerell Robinson (TE / WR) – Another undrafted player, Robinson played three games for the Miami Dolphins and Cleveland Browns in 2014, but failed to register a reception.

Retrospective

Contenders has established itself as the home of the true rookie auto, and rightfully so. This flagship product is not without it’s flaws, however, as I will continue to fight tooth and nail that enormous autograph checklists are as much a pain to collectors as they are to card manufacturers in acquiring those autographs. 2012 was a particularly memorable Contenders product for myself and a lot of my fellow coworkers at COMC, as Russell Wilson had already taken over the QB job for a Seahawks team desperately in need of a direction. The chase for Andrew Luck rookie autos will remain a memorable history point in my time at COMC. I had much better results busting 2012 Panini Contenders than I did on 2012 Topps Supreme, but that’s a story for a different day.

Sets Revisited: Grading the 2017 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph Class

Welcome to Sets Revisited, a series where we take a look at sets of years past. This time around, we’re setting the way back machine to the Summer of 2017 to evaluate one of the hottest baseball sets in the last few years. The perfect storm of Aaron Judge in the East and Cody Bellinger in the West set the hobby ablaze. Long time collectors and new collectors returning the hobby simply could not get enough of these two sluggers. With a strong supporting rookie class, 2017 Topps Chrome was the highly anticipated pinnacle of the 2017 baseball season for Topps. Although Topps continued to release sets well into the off season, nothing quite captured the magic of 2017 Topps Chrome.

Do you have a set that is near and dear to your heart and want to write about it? We’re always looking for guest writers on the COMC Blog to share their passion for cards! Send an email to Staff@COMC.com and we’d be more than happy to chat about your blog ideas!

Please note that any price speculation, player or card evaluations in this blog are the opinions of the writer – James Good  in this case, and do not reflect the same views as COMC as a company.

The A Class – aka The Money Cards

It should really be no surprise to see this group of players leading the pack as the rookie autograph cream of the crop. While Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger went back and forth in the popularity contest while each running away with their respective league’s Rookie of the Year crowns, Alex Bregman and Andrew Benintendi quietly put together campaigns that would have put them in the running for those awards in most seasons. Meanwhile, Yoan Moncada and Ian Happ showed strong promise

Judge and Bellinger autos will set you back quite a few dollars, but both have the early makings of becoming iconic cards in the industry. If they’re anything like their fellow mega stars of the game (Giancarlo Stanton & Bryce Harper come to mind), their value should rise steadily for years to come.  Benintendi, Bregman and Moncada are all more economical investment options, and could yield higher returns overall than the big two, but at a slower rate. Happ remains the wild card of the group, but has all the makings of a star and plays for a big market team, hence deserving a spot in the A Class.

 

The B Class – aka The Investment Group

I’v dubbed the next ten best cards of the 2017 Topps Chrome Rookie Auto class as ‘The Investment Group’ because several of these players have a chance to break out huge over the next several years and join the ranks of standout 2017 rookies above. Trey Mancini came into the season with a buzz and did not disappoint. His stock could rise substantially in Baltimore with the speculative departure of Manny Machado. Mitch Haniger flew under the radar for the Seattle Mariners in 2017, and despite injuries produced a stat line similar to Bregman. It wasn’t until he cranked out 10 home runs in April 2018 that his hobby stock rose significantly and the price of his ’17 Topps Chrome Auto rose from $4 to $15.

Yuli Guerriel‘s age (32) played a factor in his hobby value, but like Bregman, did have a huge spotlight shined on him (both positively and negatively) as the Astros claimed World Series glory. Teoscar Hernandez only played 26 games last year, but did hit 8 homers for Toronto after being traded in a deal that saw Francisco Liriano head to Houston. The price of his rookie auto has steadily risen ever since and his base auto is currently sold out at time of writing.

Matt Olson generated his fair share of hobby buzz by smashing 24 homers in under 60 games, but his value has tapered off in 2018 with a slow start. Josh Hader has increased his stock dramatically as a dynamic reliever who is an absolute strikeout machine. It’s likely that a large amount of Hader autos can still be found in $3 and $5 boxes at your local card shows – scoop them up because the kid is young and can deal! Hype for Alex Reyes is starting to generate as he works his way back from Tommy John surgery. He is the Cardinals top-rated prospect. Tyler Austin, David Dahl, and Ryon Healy round out the group with similar long term investment potential as the rest of the B Class, but they’ve yet to put it all together at the big league level for a sustained period of time yet. Of the three, Healy has shown above average defense and pop in his bat playing for the Seattle Mariners as their everyday first basemen. Any of these three players can get hot in an instant and when they do, their chrome starts shining a lot brighter!

The C Class – aka High Risk, High Reward

Rookie Chrome Autos for starting pitchers tend to be somewhat polarizing in the hobby – they’re either very hot or very tepid. Highly touted pitching prospects often dominate Bowman prospecting speculation, yet fail to produce similar hype initially once they reach Topps Chrome. For that reason, I’ve dubbed this class as high risk, high reward.

The C Class is rounded out by two starting pitchers who have each shown that they deserve a spot in their team’s starting rotation, but have yet to show collectors a reason to invest with urgency. Luke Weaver and Carson Fulmer have all the makings of top-of-the-rotation pitchers, but are still developing at the big league level. Jessie Winker, Lewis Brinson, Bradley Zimmer, Hunter Dozier and Franklin Barreto have yet to really make a splash in the majors, but they show all the tools to be solid everyday players. Unfortunately, in an industry that is constantly chasing the next big thing, they’ll each have to step it up to gain recognition in the hobby beyond the local scale.

The D Class – A Couple of These Guys Will Prove Everyone Wrong

*Record scratch* *Freeze Frame*
Dansby Swanson: “Yup, that’s me. You’re probably wondering how I ended up here in the D Class….”

I know that this is going to generate some buzz, and a lot of people are going to disagree with my assessment. I hope that I end up being wrong, because I fully expect at least two or more of these guys to put together great big league careers. I expect that a few of these guys certainly won’t stay in the $5 price range either. But for right now, this is where Dansby Swanson belongs. He has all the potential to be a B+ or even an A- player years from now, but he has a long road to redemption. To say that his career up to this point hasn’t gone the way that him and a lot of speculative prospectors would have hoped would be an understatement. With all the young talent that is flowing in Atlanta, Dansby is going to struggle to regain his footing in the hobby as players like Ronald Acuna and Ozzie Albies pass him by.Although he has shown flashes of brilliance at times this season, he is currently a bottom of the order hitter on a team stacked with younger, and wildly more popular talent.

Of the rest of the players in this group, I’d like to highlight Jorge Alfaro, Chad Pinder, and Hunter Renfroe as the three most likely candidates to break out of this group. Pinder has also shown to be adept with the bat – cranking out 15 home runs in 2017 but striking out around 30% of the time.

The F Class – Available in Bulk on COMC!

I’m not going to say anything bad about this group of players. Every Topps Chrome rookie auto checklist is rounded out by a crop of guys who simply aren’t buzz worthy in the hobby. Some of these guys will have decent careers or fit niche roles very well throughout their career. However, for now they will forever be the ‘hits’ that could have been. For every Aaron Judge auto pulled from a pack of chrome with excitement, there is a Joe Jimenez or Reynaldo Lopez auto hit elsewhere with little fanfare.

The good news is that if one of these players do happen to break out, a feeding frenzy of flipping (say that one three times fast!) will happen because these players are all available in bulk on the COMC Marketplace! For the sake of optimism, I’ll take Rob Gsellman and Pat Valaika as my two candidates who could shift the market with a single performance.

Overall as a whole, I’m going to give the 2017 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph class a collective grade of B+ This set has some serious potential to go down as one of the best in Topps Chrome history. Featuring two of the games most popular players with bright careers ahead, and several others with the ability to reach that level, this wasn’t a product where collectors were only chasing one big name. I highly enjoyed ripping my case of 2017 Topps Chrome in a hotel room while vacationing in North Carolina. Hitting a purple Judge auto at the height of his popularity will always be one of my favorite hobby moments, and the reason why this set is near and dear to my heart.

Behind the Cards: The Fred Hutchinson Story

(Note from COMC: The following post comes to us from the desk of Stan Opdyke, a lifelong fan of the game of baseball who started collecting cards over 60 years ago. He has an affinity for the Baltimore Orioles, his favorite team in his youngest days. Through his involvement in the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, Mr. Opdyke was inspired to research and write this brilliant look at the cards produced by the life and times of Fred Hutchinson. If you would like to submit your article to us for consideration to be published on our blog, please email us at staff@comc.com.)

Hutch-e1327186696334

Fred Hutchinson

Fred Hutchinson, at the age of 18, began his professional baseball career in 1938 as a pitcher for his hometown Seattle Rainiers of the Pacific Coast League. Baseball cards were relatively scarce items at the time, at least in comparison to what they would become after World War ll, so unsurprisingly no baseball card of Hutch was produced in his first professional season.

Hutch was sensational for the Rainiers in 1938. Pitching most of the season as an 18 year old, Hutch compiled a 25-7 won/loss record and a 2.48 ERA. On his 19th birthday on August 12, 1938, he pitched before a standing room crowd at Seattle’s Sick’s Stadium in search of his 19th victory. Hutch got the win in a game that stands with the Edgar Martinez double that defeated the Yankees in the 1995 post season as one of the most iconic baseball games ever played in Seattle.

Hutch’s superb season drew the attention of major league teams and one of the two major producers of baseball cards in the 1930’s. On December 12, 1938, the Seattle Rainiers traded Fred Hutchinson to the Detroit Tigers for four players and $50,000 Depression era dollars. The huge outlay of cash undoubtedly influenced the Goudey gum company to include Hutch in its 1939 Premium set. The other major baseball card manufacturer of the era, Play Ball, did not issue a card of Hutch in 1939. 

1939 Fred Hutchinson Goudey Premium

The 1939 Goudey Premiums are listed in the 2013 Standard Catalogue of Vintage Baseball Cards in two distinct series, R303-A and R303-B. The R303-A cards are slightly smaller but otherwise identical to the R303-B cards. Both series of 1939 Goudey Premiums are unnumbered. Hutch appears in the 303-A series. The 1939 Goudey Premiums are baseball cards in that they were issued by a gum company and depict images of baseball players. However, in other ways they are not like baseball cards at all. The smaller sized 303-A cards still measure a very large 4 inches x 6 3/16 inches, far too large to fit in anyone’s shirt pocket. The Goudey Premiums also differ from typical baseball cards because they are printed on paper stock that is about the thickness of a newspaper page. The 1939 Goudey Premiums have the look and feel of a small poster.

The photograph Goudey selected to use of Hutch is a portrait of a teenager sporting a warm grin. It is a rare photo of a smiling Fred Hutchinson. When he grew older, Hutch was given the nicknames “The Bear” and “Old Stoneface,” quite a contrast to the photo on his 1939 Goudey Premium card.

Hutch struggled in 1939.  His trouble began in Spring Training when he lost the ability to throw strikes. His lack of control would have undoubtedly cost him a major league roster spot had the Tigers not invested so much money in him. However, because of the huge cash outlay, Hutch began the 1939 season in the major leagues.

Hutch made his major league debut in one of the most significant games in baseball history. The New York Yankees played against the Tigers in Detroit on May 2, 1939, and for the first time since May 31, 1925, the name of the legendary Lou Gehrig did not appear in a regular season box score. The Yankees scored early and often without Gehrig in the line-up. With the Tigers trailing 13-0, Hutch was brought into the game by Tiger manager Del Baker. Nothing went right for Hutch. Pitching just two-thirds of an inning, he surrendered four hits, five walks and eight earned runs.

Hutch was sent to the minor league Buffalo Bisons of the International League after his disastrous major league debut. His traditional pitching numbers (won/loss and ERA) were better in Buffalo than in Detroit, but in both the major and minor leagues in 1939, his performance significantly lagged the excellent season he had for Seattle in the Pacific Coast League in 1938.

1940 Team Issued Fred Hutchinson Buffalo Bisons card

Hutch’s demotion to the minor leagues led to his second appearance on a baseball card. In 1940 the Buffalo Bisons issued a team set of baseball cards. The 1940 Bisons cards are printed on thicker paper and are much smaller then the 1939 Goudey Premium cards. The unnumbered 1940 Bisons Fred Hutchinson card shows him winding up as if he is about to deliver a pitch. The photograph was obviously staged because the picture was taken on the grass in front of a dugout rather than on a pitcher’s mound.

Hutch pitched for both Buffalo and Detroit in 1940.  Detroit won the American League pennant in 1940 and Hutch was included on the Tigers World Series roster. He pitched one World Series inning against a team he would one day manage, the Cincinnati Reds. He allowed one walk, one hit and one earned run.

In 1941 Hutch, pitching for the Buffalo Bisons, turned in a performance reminiscent of his sensational 1938 season in the Pacific Coast League. He won 26 games for Buffalo in 1941 and in 284 innings he turned in an excellent 2.44 ERA. With such a stellar season behind him, Hutch seemed destined to earn a spot on the Tigers major league roster in 1942. World War II however intervened.

Hutch enlisted in the Navy shortly before the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. He served in the Navy’s physical education program. Hutch pitched for Navy teams in Norfolk, VA, Seattle, WA, and Hawaii, so during the war he was able to keep his baseball skills sharp.

The baseball players who served in the military in World War II returned en masse to organized baseball in 1946. Hutch was part of the 1946 waive of ex-servicemen returning to professional baseball.  He spent the entire year in 1946 with the Detroit Tigers. It was the first time he spent a full season in the major leagues.

1991 Reprint of 1947 Tip Top Bread Fred Hutchinson Card

In 1947 Hutch appeared for the first time on a post war baseball card. The Tip Top Baking Company issued several regional baseball card sets in 1947 to promote the sale of Tip Top Bread. The unnumbered cards feature black and white pictures with the player’s name, position, team and league affiliation printed underneath the photo. Hutch’s Tip Top Bread card features a close up portrait of him wearing a Detroit Tigers cap.

In 1948 Hutch did not appear on a baseball card. In 1949 two gum manufacturers, Bowman and Leaf, produced baseball cards of Hutch. Fred Hutchinson’s 1949 Leaf card is his highest priced card. The 1949 Leaf set is extremely difficult to complete. About half the cards in the set are short printed and Hutch’s card is among the short printed cards. His 1949 Leaf card in excellent condition is worth $900.00. By way of comparison two other Hutch cards that are also difficult to find, his 1939 Goudey Premium card and his 1947 Tip Top Bread card, have much lower prices. His Goudey Premium card in excellent condition lists at $75.00 and his 1947 Tip Top Bread card in excellent condition lists at $150.00. (All prices are from the 2013 Standard Catalogue of Vintage Baseball Cards.)

In 1950, Bowman was the only gum company to produce baseball cards. Hutch is included in the 1950 Bowman set. His 1950 Bowman card is derived from a painting that was transformed into a baseball card. The painting depicts Hutch at the very end of his follow through after delivery of a pitch. Bowman got good mileage out of the painting because they used again in 1951. That same year, Hutch was named to the American League All Star team. He pitched three innings in the 1951 mid-summer classic.

In 1952 Hutch made his first appearance on a Topps card. Topps produced its first baseball card set a year earlier, but in its initial set the company did not issue a card of Fred Hutchinson.  Topps made up for its 1951 omission by producing a magnificent card of Hutch in the 1952 set. Bowman again used a painting to create the front of its baseball cards. The artist hired to paint Fred Hutchinson must have noticed the look on Hutch’s face after he had surrendered a long home run.

The Tigers had a miserable year in 1952, almost as miserable as the look on Hutch’s face on his 1952 Bowman card. On July 5th, with the club in last place, Tiger manager Red Rolfe was fired and Hutch was hired to replace him. Hutch remained on the Tigers active playing roster after he took over as manager. He continued in his dual role as a player and a manager in 1953.

Both Topps and Bowman included a card of Hutch in their 1953 sets. Topps took a page from Bowman by using a painting as the template for the front of its 1953 cards. Bowman emulated Topps by issuing a larger baseball card in 1953 than it had produced from 1948 to 1952. (Bowman did not issue a card of Hutch in 1948).  The 1953 Bowman set is considered by most collectors as one of the best baseball card sets ever produced. Hutch’s 1953 Bowman card is representative of the picture quality that exists throughout the set.

Hutch retired as an active player after the 1953 season.  He managed the Tigers for one year after retiring as a player. Neither Topps nor Bowman included managers in their 1954 sets, so 1954 marked the first time since 1948 that Fred Hutchinson did not appear on a baseball card.
After the 1954 season ended Hutch informed the Tigers he wanted a two year contract. The Tigers refused to offer more than one year. The impasse led to Hutch’s departure from Detroit when he refused to sign the one year contact he was offered.

Hutch was out of a job, but he was not out of baseball. In 1955 he returned to his hometown to manage the Seattle Rainiers to a Pacific Coast League pennant.  A year before Hutch”s arrival, the Rainiers began issuing baseball cards to fans who purchased popcorn at the team’s home games. Seattle minor league teams issued popcorn cards every year from 1954 through 1968.  It is hardly surprising that Hutch, the popular hometown manager, was included in the popcorn cards the team produced in 1955.

In 1956 Hutch returned to the major leagues to manage the St Louis Cardinals.  Topps was the only gum company that manufactured baseball cards during the three years Hutch managed the Cardinals.

 

Topps did not issue a card of Hutch while he managed in St. Louis. Topps  included few cards of managers in the sets it produced from 1956 to 1958. Brooklyn’s Walt Alston and Philadelphia’s Mayo Smith were the only managers Topps included in its 1956 set.  No managers were included in the 1957 set. In 1958 Topps issued only two cards of managers, a card of Reds manager Birdie Tebbetts with two of his players, Frank Robinson and Ed Bailey, and a card on which managers Casey Stengel and Fred Haney appeared together.

Hutch enjoyed some success with the Cardinals. In 1957, St. Louis finished in second place, fueling expectations that the team would contend for the pennant in 1958. However in 1958 the Cardinals played poorly, and as a consequence, Hutch was fired shortly before the 1958 season ended.

In 1959 Hutch returned to Seattle to once again manage the Rainiers. His second stint with the club lasted only three months. He was in town long enough though to appear in the 1959 edition of Seattle Rainiers popcorn cards.

In the middle of the 1959 season, Cincinnati Reds manager Mayo Smith was fired. Hutch was chosen to replace him.  Hutch managed the Cincinnati Reds to a 1961 World Series appearance. As was customary, he served as the National League All Star manager the following year. As a result of managing in the 1962 All Star game, Hutch became one of about a dozen men in baseball history (Hank Bauer, Yogi Berra and Alvin Dark are a few of the others) to manage and play in a World Series and manage and play in an All Star game.

Hutch remained the manager of the Reds until deteriorating health caused him to take a leave of absence in 1964. Hutch appeared in each baseball card set Topps produced from 1960 through 1964.

In late December of 1963 Hutch was diagnosed with cancer. He died of the disease eleven months after he was diagnosed. Between diagnosis and death, Hutch managed the Cincinnati Reds for most of the 1964 season. The determination and courage Hutch displayed during his last baseball season is told by Bruce Markusen in his excellent Hardball Times article, available online, “The Final Year of Fred Hutchinson’s Life.”

Hutch resigned as the manager of the Reds in a letter he sent to team owner Bill DeWitt dated October 11, 1964. Exactly one month later he died in Bradenton, Florida.