Dear unhappy customer

To whom it may concern,

Today we got your letter regarding one or more cards you were unhappy with. We would love to help resolve your issue, but you didn’t give us any contact information or any information about the item(s) you purchased. We have shipped out more than 100,000 items this month, so we really have no clue which items you are referring to.

Please contact us, and we will gladly resolve your issue.

Thanks you for taking the time to let us know you were unhappy with the order. I hope you have a happy new year, and we would love to be given the opportunity to make you a happy customer.

Tim Getsch Founder & CEO

Item #6,000,000 just hit the site

Item #6000000, submitted by arcaiser
1996-97 Ultra Decade of Excellence #U1 - Clyde Drexler - Courtesy of

Here is a quote from CheckOutMyDeals who discovered that item #6000000 was live before we did. I guess we have been a little preoccupied with our move.

I think it’s wonderful that not only did you process an additional 1 million cards in record time, but you also improved the site to address at least 2 of the user’s top concerns since card #5000000 was processed.

People wanted an easy port sale feature and they now have it.

People wanted an increased customer base, and you’re now cross-posting cards to Amazon, potentially adding millions of new customers.

Some features I would love to see:

* The ability to tag players with Hall of Fame status, All Star status, major awards won, teams played on, etc.

* The ability to tag sets / cards as autographed or memorabilia cards.

* The ability to filter searches by several factors. For instance Yankees memorabilia cards over $10 book value that are at least 50% off book value.

One feature I would really like to see:

The ability for a seller to subdivide their port into several smaller ports. The port could then be sold as a bulk lot using the port sale feature. It could also be subjected to different auto accept percentages than other cards.

That way, if someone wants to accept 50% offers on basketball cards but only accept 10% offers on baseball cards, they could do so. Or if they would sell their hockey for 10% of book, but only as a bulk lot, they could also do so.

I’m very happy with COMC and all of the positive improvements that you are continually making. Good luck!

Let’s see how many of these feature requests are live by the time item #7000000 hits the site.

Side Note
Over the last few months we knew we were running out of space in our current warehouse, and we chose to spend our energies hunting for a new home instead of giving specials or trying to get more items on the site. As a result it took us 2 days longer to get from item #5000000 to #6000000 (137 days) than it did to get from #4000000 to #5000000 (135 days). This is actually quite amazing when you consider the fact that we ran virtually no processing specials during that time. When we don’t run any specials, people send us cards that are more difficult and time consuming to process. One way to approximate the difficulty of the cards submitted is by looking at the average book value. Generally the more valuable a card is the more rare it is and the harder to identify what it is.

As you can see from this chart, we had been hovering around $5/item for an average book value the past few years. Over the last 6 months as we have been working on the items in the 5,000,000’s you can see that our average book value shot up to just under $6/item. It was quite a feat to get all of those items processed in virtually the same amount of time as the previous million items.

For the next million items we will have room to hire more people and give them enough space to work efficiently. We will see how this translates to our stats.

Following in the Footsteps of Zillow

“Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity.” – Seneca

We have spent the last 4+ years growing to the point where we are ready to now take a big leap into a 27,000 sqft building. As part of the move & expansion, we needed to buy some additional furniture. Last week we were hunting for a conference table, couch and some other furniture on craigslist when we got “lucky” and discovered a large amount of furniture that was being moved from an skyscraper in downtown Seattle.

Their plan was to move the office furniture to warehouse in Kent where the public could pick through it, and they would liquidate it over the next week. We mentioned that we might be willing to take all of it, and they allowed us to swing by and look through it before they began the move. So, last week we visited the skyscraper and were waiting for the security guard to let us in to the office when we discovered that Zillow had just moved, and we were at their old headquarters. You can take a tour of Zillow’s new HQ. When they moved, they opted to get all new furniture. Ironically, they had taken the same strategy as we have done, and their old furniture was nearly all recycled furniture originally from Microsoft. Walking through their old head quarters, we found ourselves literally following in the footsteps of Zillow.

For a little more than the cost of moving, we have acquired more than enough furniture to furnish our entire building and then some. The total came to about 30 truck loads. We have been joking about launching a new site… It is nice to think that we are building for the future on furniture that was originally purchased by the largest Seattle area tech startup (Microsoft) and most recently used by a company that was considered the largest Seattle area startup by for many years (Zillow). The only reason they are no longer on top of the Seattle Startup Index is that they are no longer considered a startup.

We will do our best to continue the tradition, and use this furniture to launch our company to new heights.

Helping the Spirit of Christmas

We received the following email this week from a new customer.

Growing up, my father collected baseball cards. Like most boys from the 1950’s – he would swap cards with his buddies. One of his pals was always trying to “trade up” by offering several smaller cards for a big one. His pal would often try to sweeten the pot by throwing a couple of Bill Henry cards in for the trade. As a child, anytime my siblings and I would try to make unfair trades with each other, my father would often say “Why don’t you throw in a couple of Bill Henry’s?” We never knew what this meant. My father just used this phrase on one of his grandkids – so I heard the story once again, and a light bulb went off: my father needs a Bill Henry card. On a whim, I looked up your sight, and there it was – waiting for me. I ordered it and just received it in the mail. It is in excellent condition, and I can’t wait for my father to open it this Christmas. The best $7 I ever spent. THANK YOU SO MUCH! And Merry Christmas

This is the reason for what we do. Beyond business, past capitalism, there is a beating heart to this hobby that is capable of connecting people in a very real and profound way. It is a genuine pleasure to do what we do, and an honor to live in a country where a unique business concept like ours is not just possible but embraced.
Thanks for making all this possible.

Merry Christmas from COMC.

Really BIG News + Holiday Shipping

‘Tis the season to be jolly, and we have 27,000 new reasons to be jolly!

If you have followed our site for any time, you probably noticed how rapidly we have been growing. We moved into a 2,000 sqft warehouse just under 4 years ago, took less than two years to outgrow that, and upgraded to a 6,000 sqft warehouse. Again we took less than 2 years to outgrow that. This time we are making a huge leap to a 27,000 sqft building. We just signed the lease yesterday,and we are starting to make plans for orchestrating the move.

Holiday Shipping
In honor of the 27 thousand sqft that we are moving to, we came up with a 27¢ special.
Normally our standard shipping is $3 for the first card and 25¢ for each additional card.

From now until December 27th, we will ship the first 11 cards for only $3.
That comes out to $0.2727272727272…. per card for the first 11 cards.

No account required. No extra fee for international orders. All cards will be shipped in penny sleeves. Normal extra fees apply for toploaders, graded or jumbo cards.
See Shipping Policy for full details.

Thank you to for giving us the permission to use this photo. They are a great source of aerial photography!