trauty closes in on 100K mark

Andy Kimball stumbled upon sports cards when he was 8, using money that was dedicated for Halloween candy.

“My mom and stepdad had some crazy idea that my sister and I weren’t going to go trick-or-treating, and instead, we were given $10 to buy candy at the store,” Kimball recalls. ” I’m not sure why, but for some reason I ended up buying a couple football packs.”

Exactly 30 years later, Kimball estimates he owns “3 million, maybe 4 million” cards. And any day now, Kimball (user name trauty) will become the 10th COMC seller to ever reach $100,000 in total book value (of cards listed).

Kimball, who was born in Ohio, moved to Indiana when he was three months old and lived there for 10 years. Due to Kimball’s father being a store manager for Kroger, relocating would be a staple of Kimball’s life.

2009 Upper Deck Gold #459 - Zack Greinke Gil Meche David DeJesus TL/99 - Courtesy of CheckOutMyCards.comAfter spending a year in Kansas (which explains the fact that his favorite professional team is the Kansas City Royals), Kimball lived in Nebraska for the next decade and a half and worked various jobs following high school while also doing several card shows annually.

After a brief stint in Oklahoma, Kimball moved back to Nebraska and bought his friend’s card shop. “That didn’t work out so well,” recalls Kimball, who went back to Oklahoma after about a year.

2001 Quantum Leaf #219 - Correll Buckhalter SP RC (Rookie Card) - Courtesy of
The Sooner State is where Kimball still resides, with his wife and two children. But during Big 12 football seasons, there’s only one team he’s rooting for: his Cornhuskers, of course.

Kimball, who lives in Talihina (with a population of about 1,500  in the southeast corner of Oklahoma), was a seller on Beckett Marketplace from 2002-04 but stopped because he “hated the shipping and having to deal with all that”. Kimball’s cards sat, for the most part, for the next five years before becoming a seller on COMC 10 months ago.

“I think I’m about $1,000 away (from reaching 100K),” said Kimball when we spoke earlier this week.

If his current pace continues, Kimball will be there in no time.

2006 Exquisite Collection Gold #123 - Leon Washington JSY AU/99 - Courtesy of 2004 Press Pass Autographs #16 - Dale Earnhardt Jr. E - Courtesy of

7 thoughts on “trauty closes in on 100K mark

  1. What’s book value? Isn’t that an antiquated pricing made null and void by sites such as yours, sportsbuy, and ebay? I’d be more impressed if that was the threshhold of realized value he has sold on your site.

    • Im curious to the amount realized too…It would be nice to see the final sale prices on some of the cards to get an idea of what actual values are…

    • Regardless of how accurate the book value correlates to actual sales value, it is a reasonable metric for the total quantity of cards for sale on the site.

  2. Actually, seeing actual sales and searches would greatly aid this site.
    If I see certain cards active I can then determine that it makes sense for me to send them
    in to get sold through the site. Having lots of cards on that the public does not want to
    buy would not help me at all, and cost me the storage + scanning fees.

  3. Andy, I thought you started your collection by ‘appropriating’ my tiny baseball card collection that I’d lost interest in? Who knew? 🙂

    Cool article however!

    Ben (Trauty’s older brother)

Comments are closed.